Three-Thousand Irishmen

Sir Francis Drake
Sir Francis Drake

In 1845, in the waning years of Mexican rule, a Catholic Priest and former missionary in British Guinea, Fr. Eugene Macnamara (1814-1853) had a big idea which he began to promote in Mexico City.

He proposed that the Mexican government should allow 3000 families (this could amount to 10-12,000 people) from Ireland to immigrate to California and settle along the coast of California. There were only about 75,000 people in California in 1845, so an influx of this size would boost the population significantly. Their catholic religion would help the Irish assimilate quickly and remain loyal to the Mexican government, he argued. Macnamara implied that the scheme had the backing of the British government. The Mexican authorities were receptive and Fr. Macnamara was granted a land contract and encouraged to precede.

There is no hard documentary evidence that McNamara’s plan had the formal approval of the British government, but Britain did have a special interest in California.

For one thing, almost two centuries earlier, during his three year (1577-1589) circumnavigation of the globe, the famous British explorer Sir Francis Drake sailed along the coast of California.

FREDERICK BEECHEY
FREDERICK BEECHEY

In May 1579 he pulled into a harbor to repair his ship, the Golden Hind, making extensive and peaceful contact with the natives. Historians debate the exact location but it was somewhere near San Francisco. Drake claimed the land for Queen Elizabeth and named it Nova Albion. A colonizing party was dispersed by the Spanish off the coast of Brazil, and no further attempts were made by the English to occupy this land. However, Britain felt that if any country was to succeed Mexico in governing California, they had a stronger claim that any other major powers.

California became more well known to the English in 19th century. Frederick Beechey (1796-1856) visited California in 1826 during a scientific expedition to the Pacific.

SAN CARLOS 1826
SAN CARLOS 1826

In 1831 Captain (later Admiral) Beechey published a book Narratives of a Voyage to the Pacific and Bering's Strait.that stirred considerable interest in this wondrous land. Sketches made by Beechey’s expedition artist included this pencil and watercolor drawing “the Mission of San Carlos, Monterey.”

By this time there were already a significant number of former British subjects in Alta California, many of them with financial and political clout. William Edward Petty Hartnell (1798-1854) had arrived in 1822 and had become a successful hide and tallow merchant.

William Edward Petty Hartnell (1798-1854)
William Edward Petty Hartnell (1798-1854)

In 1839 Hartnell had been appointed to the politically sensitive position of Visitator General, overseeing the administration of the former missions.

Robert Livermore (1799-1858) arrived the same year as Hartnell. He was the first settler of Livermore Valley.

Another Englishman, William Richardson was Captain of the Port of San Francisco. He had married the daughter of the presidio Commandante, and had a close working relationship with the most powerful man in Northern California, General Mariano Vallejo.

John Forster (1815-1882) arrived in Los Angeles in 1833 and was already accumulating land and considerable wealth.

OLD BALE MILL
OLD BALE MILL

Dr. Edward Turner Bale arrived directly from England in 1837, married a niece of General Vallejo in 1839. He had received a large land grant, Rancho Carne Humana, in Napa Valley in 1841. He built a successful that supplied most of Napa Valley.

William Workman, yet another Englishman had organized the first wagon train of eastern settlers to Southern California in 1841, coming via New Mexico along the Old Spanish Trail.

Old Spanish Trail
Old Spanish Trail

Encourage by all these factors, Fr. Macnamara visited Alta California in 1846 to try to get local support for his scheme. It soon became clear that all the choice land along the coast had been granted. Whatever informal British support existed quickly evaporated when it became clear that any land for the Irish immigrants would be far inland, probably in the San Juaquin Valley.

Fr. Macnamara pressed ahead anyway and spent a month and a half visiting potential sites and building local support. However while Macnamara was still in California, the Americans occupied Monterey, and began a takeover of the entire country.

IRISH IMMIGRANTS EMBARKING FOR UNITED STATES
IRISH IMMIGRANTS EMBARKING FOR UNITED STATES

Macnamara made his way back to Mexico to continue to push his scheme but the idea was overtaken by events. He is rumored to have died at sea rounding Cape Horn sometime in 1853. An Irish Historian who tried to find more about his fate concluded “he is lost to history and left to the tender mercy of memories.”

Ironically while Fr. Macnamara was pursuing his scheme, Irish were beginning to arrive in America in increasing numbers due to the Irish Potato Famine.

GOV. JOHN DOWNEY (1861-62)
GOV. JOHN DOWNEY (1861-62)

In October 1845, a serious blight began among the Irish potatoes, ruining about three-quarters of the country's crop. This was a disaster as many people in Ireland depended on the potato as their chief food. The blight returned in 1846 and over the next year an estimated 350,000 people died of starvation. The famine stimulated emigration of a scale that made Fr. Macnamara’s proposal look almost irrelevant. In 1846 data shows that 92,484 Irish arrived in America and the figure doubled the next year to 196,224. While most of the Irish arrived and stayed on the east coast hundreds made their way to California.

In less than two decades after Fr. Macnamara’s scheme was proposed a man born in Ireland, John Downey, became governor of California. Downey was an early emigrant to America (1818) who was drawn to California during the gold rush, although he made most of his money in real estate.

Whether Fr. Macnamara was a visionary or not, the Irish certainly did make their way to California.